"""For me, the
issue of which of the British or American
versions of
Queer As Folk is """"superior"""" is pointless and self-defeating. It's like asking which of the
Star Trek series is superior. The British
version of
Queer As Folk laid the foundation upon which the American
version has successfully built and expanded. No doubt, however, that it's about
halfway through the first
season, once the script breaks away from the
storylines of the British
version, where the American
version finally hits its stride.
The
cast deserves kudos as well. Nearly every scene in
Queer As Folk (and not just the sex
scenes) requires the actors to go above and beyond the call of
duty and bare deeply buried
emotions. Hal Sparks is awkwardly charming as gay Everyman Michael, the
character most viewers, gay and straight, will identify with. Randy Harrison shines in his breakout
role as 17 year old Justin, the quintessential
portrait of middle class American gay youth. (Yet the writing of his
character reveals the one true weakness of this
show, and American
television & film in general: gay youth are consistently portrayed as good looking, spoiled, college bound, having money to burn, and white. When are we going to see a realistic
portrayal of working class or minority gay youth?) The rest of the
cast fill their
roles admirably, but it's Gale Harold who steals the
show as Brian, easily the most complex
character on television today. Brian is a promiscuous, man-stealing, drug-using
jerk who almost qualifies for the """"J. R. Ewing you'll love to hate him"""" award. Yet in many ways he's the hero if the
show, sticking to his own rather unusual code of ethics, calling others on their own
hypocrisy, and, in spite of himself, almost always doing the right thing. Note that it's Brian who's constantly protecting Michael and coming to Justin's
rescue."""
------------------
stardvdcityThe Sopranos DVD 1-6Monk DVD 1-8Queer As Folk DVD 1-5Law and Order DVD 1-10Two and a Half Men DVD 1-7One Tree Hill DVD 1-7Doctor Who DVD 1-5Bones DVD 1-5Desperate Housewives DVD 1-6 The Big Bang Theory DVD 1-3The Vampire Diaries DVDGhost Whisperer DVD 1-5How I Met Your Mother DVD 1-5Gossip Girl DVD 1-3Brothers and Sisters DVD 1-4Alias DVD 1-5House MD DVD 1-6Smallville DVD 1-9Navy NCIS DVD 1-7Supernatural DVD 1-5Criminal Minds DVD 1-5South Park DVD 1-13The Tribe DVD 1-5